|
|
Family-Centered Care Award Summaries
Each year at the Society of Critical Care Medicine's annual Critical Care Congress, the Society's Patient and Family Support Committee awards the Family-Centered Care Award. The award recognizes innovation that improves the care provided to critically ill and injured patients and their families. Listed below is the 2010 award recipient and honorable mention. For award recipients and honorable mentions from previous years, please visit the Family-Centered Care Award Archives.
Learn about next year's award and the application process.
2010 Family-Centered Care Award Summaries
At the 39th Annual Critical Care Congress, SCCM's Patient and Family Support Committee awarded the sixth annual Family-Centered Care Award to Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in in Boston, Massachusetts for their person-centered critical care. Honorable mention was given to the Hospital de Clinicas Caracas in Caracas, Venezuela for their Family-Oriented Support Unit.
Award Recipient BETH ISRAEL DEACONESS MEDICAL CENTER, PERSON-CENTERED CRITICAL CARE Boston, MA
In late 2007, the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center’s (BIDMC's) Critical Care Executive Committee unanimously selected developing person-centered critical care as their next major quality improvement priority. As with prior quality efforts, they included all nine of their ICUs in the improvement plan.
To be truly patient and family-centered, the center allowed patients and families to set their improvement priorities by assembling the ICU Patient and Family Advisory Council, a group of former ICU patients and families (of both survivors and non-survivors). Initial selection of members included in-person interviews by a social worker and a member of the Critical Care Quality staff to assure exceptional advice and guidance. Additionally, in April 2008, the center began administering the FS-ICU to families of ICU survivors within three days of transfer out of the ICU and mailing it to families of non-survivors several weeks after the patient’s death. The center has surveyed nearly 400 families to date. Based on themes and specifics gathered from the ICU Patient and Family Advisory Council and the FS-ICU, the BIDMC has improved in the following ways:
Communication
- Set up a program in which all medical house officers (>150 physicians) rotate through the Simulation Center, receiving didactic and high-fidelity simulation sessions on conducting family meetings
- Created a process to prevent stress during the move from the Cardivascular ICU to a regular floor in which RNs from both areas perform a hand-off in front of the patient, with a focus on pain management
- Began a pilot in October 2009 to actively invite and include families on multidisciplinary work rounds
- Developed an introductory brochure that covers information on staff roles in the ICU, the day-to-day logistics of visiting (such as parking), and pointers to additional information and information about how families should take care of themselves
- Utilized chaplaincy staff who actively solicit patient and family needs by proactively rounding in the ICUs; the chaplaincy was recently covered in a major metropolitan newspaper
Critical Care Experience
- Created a new waiting room (the “Family Room”) and two rooms to provide overnight accommodations for families
- Eliminated formal visiting hours to help accommodate family members who work late and allow loved ones to visit at their convenience
- Gave pagers to families that allow them to go to the coffee shop, cafeteria, and nearby shops with confidence that the ICU team can page them if they are needed
- Provided Web access for families to use social networking to update extended families and friends and to keep up with some employment duties while being close to loved ones
- Installed public computers in their revitalized family room which open to a customized ICU Web site including links to online medical resources such as the Society's official Patient and Family Web site
- Contracted with CarePages to include an infrastructure at the center supporting patient- and family-created blogs about their acute health challenge. These private and personalized Web pages allow families to share the latest news with friends and family and receive messages of support without the time and effort required to call large numbers of people.
To evaluate the effectiveness of its new person-centered critical care, the BIDMC supports a half-time nurse leader dedicated to the program and substantial fractions of the Director of Critical Care Quality (an MD), the Director of Social Work, and a Masters-trained Critical Care Project Manager as well as the non-trivial capital investment required for their waiting room revitalization. They also use the FS-ICU to measure family-centered outcomes of their work and have seen consistent improvements in families’ ratings of overall satisfaction with decision-making.
The Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center is congratulated and commended for its strong commitment to improving both communication in the ICU as well as the critical care experience.

Shown above: the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Person-Centered Critical Care Team from left to right*
Back row: Michael Howell, MD, MPH, Director of Critical Care Quality; Julie Irish, PhD, Director, Office of Education Research; Lachlan Forrow, MD, Director of Ethics and Palliative Care; Barbara Sarnoff Lee, LICSW, Director of Social Work; Patricia Hall, Unit Coordinator; Robin Griggs, RN, Nurse Manager; Peter Clardy, MD, Associate MICU Director; Jean Campbell, RN, Nurse Manager; Stephanie Harriston-Diggs, Director of Volunteer Services; Jane Foley, RN, MA, Director of Operations
Front row: Sabrina Cannistraro, MS, Critical Care Quality Project Manager; Maureen Bisognano, ICU Patient and Family Advisory Council Member; Sue Pomfred, ICU Patient and Family Advisory Council Member; John Pomfred, ICU Patient and Family Advisory Council Member; Sharon O'Donoghue, RN, Clinical Nurse Specialist; Kristin Russell, RN, Nurse Manager
*Team members not pictured include Pamela Browall, RN, Nurse Manager, Coronary Care Unit; Wendy McHugh, RN, MS, Coordinator, Person-Center Critical Care Project; Cindy Phelan, RN, MS, Senior Director, Cardiovascular Institute; Joe Previtera, RRT, Manager, Respiratory Therapy; Marjorie Serrano, RN, MS, Nurse Manager, Cardiac/Vascular Surgery ICU; Daniel Talmor, MD, MPH, Director, Surgical and Trauma ICUs
Honorable Mention HOSPITAL DE CLINICAS CARACAS, FAMILY-ORIENTED SUPPORT UNIT Caracas, Venezuela
In 1994, the ICU staff at the Hospital de Clinicas Caracas detected problems affecting their patients’ families and, after careful study, established the Family-Oriented Support Unit (FOSU), assembling a multidisciplinary team of critical care physicians and nurses, bioethicists, and clinical psychologists to accomplish the following:
- Psychological evaluation and implementation of a psychotherapy process for each family using procedures such as intervention during crisis, emotional support, end-of-life family support, patient crisis intervention, respect of ethical principles, communicational connection, and management of sensorial overload. Since the FOSU was created in 1996, a total of 7,915 patient’s families have received this support from the team.
- Meetings between members of the team and each family at the end of every clinical round. Psychologists on the team now keep permanent communication open between families and health professionals.
- Entire team discussion during clinical rounds about withholding and withdrawal treatments in end-of-life care. To improve this process, a worksheet guide was designed to assure the rights of the patient and their family were correctly followed. When the decision of withholding or withdrawing is made, the team increases communication between the team and family, relocates patients to quieter FOSU areas, and allows families to stay with patients while the team monitors pain and suffering. A representative from the patient and family’s religion is also called upon by the FOSU to provide support according to their religious and cultural beliefs.
- ICU nurse, physician, and resident training, specifically in how to deliver bad news and manage grief or anger. The FOSU’s psychologists are further dedicated to the team by monitoring all professionals, watching for burnout and high stress signs.
- Utilization of bioethicists to promote an ethical approach to considering patient and family’s rights in every aspect of their treatment
- Change from traditional restricted visiting time to a free visiting schedule, coordinated by the FOSU psychologist during the day and nurses at night
- An informational brochure describing ICU characteristics, giving recommendations for families, and summarizing rights, given to families as soon as their relatives are admitted
To evaluate the effectiveness of its new FOSU and multidisciplinary team, the hospital has done a variety of studies, including but not limited to “Family psychology support unit in the ICU,” “ICU staff burnout,” “Effectiveness of a guide worksheet during end of life care.” Many of their studies have been presented in meetings and some, published. They have also organized courses about clinical bioethics and communication skills for health professionals.
The Hospital de Clinicas Caracas is congratulated and commended for their initiative and success in improving their ICU.

Shown above: the Hospital de Clinicas Caracas Family-Oriented Support Unit Team from left to right*
Back Row: Juan Pal Otero, MD, Critical Care Attending Physician; Susana Pereira, ICU Clinical Psychologist; Pablo Pérez d’Empaire, MD, Critical Care Attending Physician; Carme Virginia Mujica, ICU Clinical Pyschologist
Middle Row: Elina Siviero, Critical Care Nurse; Lolibel Quintero, Critical Care Nurse; Ivis Ruiz, Critical Care Education Manager Nurse; Yelitza Descailles, Critical Care Nurse; Gabriel d’Empaire, MD, ICU Director
Front Row: Dulce Hernandez, Critical Care Nurse; Ingrid Henriquez, Critical Care Nurse
*Team members not pictured include Maria Eugenia Fernández, MD, Master on Bioethics; Maria Isabel Parada, ICU Clinical Psychologist; Jenny Espinoza, ICU Clinical and Health Psychologist; Fernando Pérez Barreto, MD, Critical Care Attending Physician; Stevens Salva Sutherland, MD, Critical Care Attending Physician; Mercedes Delgado, Critical Care Nurse Manager |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
|